ALW's Cinderella - Gillian Lynne / U.K. Tour (rumour)

Yes I guess that's possible, but why would she go to such lengths to write a detailed response like that only to delete it? It seems unlikely because there was nothing wrong with anything she said.

How strange? I can’t see it.

Definitely there! It’s a way down the list now

Ah Burly Bear you found it thank you it appears it has reappeared ‘edited’
The HVC acknowledged Carrie’s comment with a ‘like’ and highlighted her comment
What else is there to say? Seems little point in discussing further - she’s given her opinion? It just prolongs the convo and as we’ve seen Carrie does have a tendency to indulge in a bit of back and forth.
Best to leave it at that with them both having their say possibly.

I think if you put yourself out there on social media to the extent that she does, then you are setting yourself up for criticism.

It’s a shame she can’t be a bit more humble and just say “I had an off day” rather than 7000 words blaming the stage, the crowd size blah blah blah.

I don’t know any other performer who has said anything other than performing at WEL is a great experience and they loved it.

It wasn't just an "off day", she might say that if it was a little below her usual standard. Her claim that these other factors affected her performance is borne out by this particular performance being an anomaly in her output, something which should have been acknowledged by HVC (if she was truly honest), with reference to her other work. HVC should have done some background research on the performer before posting her review. HVC should also have pinned CHF's reply, so that people watching could see both the review and also CHF's response. Treating the singer's reply to the video as if it has only the same interest and importance as any of the other Youtuber responses is disrespectful I feel.  

No, it's HVC who has drawn attention to the performance not CHF. I would have done the same thing in Carrie's position. 

That she coped alright at the Albert Hall would seem to support my argument that this subpar performance of hers was a one off. With regard to your second point, yes I do think you need to provide some context for your audience to offer an honest critique of the performance. 

I think the problem is that this vocal coach women likely DID know that something had happened regarding the performance. Otherwise why react to it? Of all the performances on YT, even of all the WEL performances on YT... She picked the only one that was taken down in an official capacity. If she specifically wanted to react to Bad Cinderella, I'm I am pretty sure Carrie's sung it at other events with way better sound and officially filmed and still available video. I don't believe she didn't know what she was reviewing, which is why I think what she did was incredibly poor form. She was specifically trying to tear someone down over a performance she knew had issues. That's not being a vocal coach, that's being a b****.

No it isn't, she has already reacted positively to previous performance. Not bad form at all, Carrie is a professional being paid to do a job. Criticism is part of it, the same with all of us in jobs. Carrie makes constant excuses, this happened when she was in Heathers too, and at WEL I think as well. I never see any other performer constantly make excuses, argue everything, and not support fellow cast members like she does.

I think Carrie's lack of training shows, she isn't used to criticism or performing outside the rehearsal room. Training would have prepared her for these situations like every other west end professional there. Things go wrong, it's how you handle it. She could have just said 'yeah sorry I messed up' but instead it's essays of excuses that just drag out the negative publicity....and negative publicity is all cinderella seems to be getting

In which case I think that makes it worse! There's nothing to gain from tearing apart the WEL performance if she's already commented on the song, other than specifically to tear apart that specific performance, and thus the performer too. Showcasing a performance that went wrong due to things completely outside of the performer's control is not a good example of anything except poor judgement on behalf of the woman making the video, imo. It speaks volumes that she hasn't taken it down.

My apologies for not trawling through all the pages for it, but what was out of the performers control?