|
Post by Deleted on Sept 16, 2016 10:53:27 GMT
The difference between the objectification of men and women is that men have not been historically and consistently reduced to *only* an object of sexual desire. The objectification of both sexes is problematic in its own right, but it's only part of continued oppression and belittlement for one sex. Yes I understand that but does that make it OK to objectify men? I have a 'friend' who really is quite sexually aggressive to straight men 'well they do it to women so I'm seeing if they like it'
|
|
1,325 posts
|
Post by londonmzfitz on Sept 16, 2016 10:54:22 GMT
I do find hilarious, on this whole forum, how much men get objectified! If someone where to say 'phooa it's a Stallen in her knickers is the reason I'm going back to soandso' would one not be branded a pig? What is it with gay men and it being ok to objectify other men? (Obs I'm a mincer myself but have always felt, in day to day life too, really weirded out by this) I'd object, and strongly, if the comments regarding the actor/actress were nasty or unpleasant. I think it's a nod to the quality of this open forum that I can openly admire the voice/face/arse of an actor without feeling I'm going to get battered by the pc brigade. If I said (and rightly) that Adam Linstead had gorgeous hair, who would complain? If I said (and rightly) that Darius Campbell was handsome who does it hurt?
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 16, 2016 10:56:07 GMT
Oh no, I absolutely agree, it's problematic and it's gross, it's just not *entirely* a double standard, and frankly your 'friend' should realise that and not misguidedly exacerbate the issue. After all, if a man gets cat-called in the street, he's MUCH less likely to immediately run through the escape plan he's had in his head since he was 11 years old, knowing that it *could* be a misguided attempt at a compliment, but equally knowing he *could* be about to end up a crime statistic, and if he encounters a sexually aggressive member of the opposite sex without fearing for his life, it's just not going to go into his head that women REALLY don't like it.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 16, 2016 11:17:19 GMT
I mean, if you think about it, political correctness is just about ensuring people treat each other with respect, and using terms like "PC Brigade" really helps obscure the original intent behind the idea, in much the same way some people think "Feminazi" is a GREAT word to use (and I honestly wouldn't be surprised if people haven't had the thought about me when I'm in one of my more argumentative moods ). If we all continue to treat each other with respect, we don't have anything to worry about, and if you do one day bust out an "excuse me miss, I just wanted to say that's a lovely skirt, have a nice day" and are met with hostility, don't take it personally, 'cos we're not yet in a world where everyone does treat each other with respect so that's a history she's carrying with her which makes her less receptive to entirely innocent and genuine compliments because she's had so much bulls**t before then and will inevitably have more in the future. ANYWAY!
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 16, 2016 11:32:52 GMT
How about when members specifically go on about seeing actors male actors naked on stage? Would it be acceptable saying the same about female actors?
I'm not being a sod here
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 16, 2016 11:33:23 GMT
Seriously? You are one of the most interesting and articulate thinkers on this board, baemax. I know we don't agree on much, but the discussion is always fascinating, and certainly not fascist. THAT RIGHT THERE is a great example of a man complimenting a woman, folks! Re: Tourette's - "coprolalia" is a good word to tuck away in your vocabulary, if "abusive-word-verbal-tick" ever gets a bit much. That's Jess Thom, right, the channel 4 continuity announcer? She's great, I highly recommend her website www.touretteshero.com/ if you ever wanted to lose three solid days to reading a personal, enlightening, fascinating, hilarious, and heartbreaking account of living with a disability.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 16, 2016 11:34:54 GMT
I grew up in a female household so objectifying women was a no no and Iv had no prob scolding men that do.
But since moving to Brighton I've found that men openly objectify men and I have no idea what I should think
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 16, 2016 11:38:13 GMT
How about when members specifically go on about seeing actors male actors naked on stage? Would it be acceptable saying the same about female actors? I'm not being a sod here Nah, it's the same sort of situation. It's more acceptable to say these things about a male actor than a female actor. I can think it's equally gross, but because of the history behind these things, it's still not technically a double-standard. The praise of the male form has never really come at the expense of the rest of the man in the way it historically has for women.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 16, 2016 11:41:38 GMT
I grew up in a female household so objectifying women was a no no and Iv had no prob scolding men that do. But since moving to Brighton I've found that men openly objectify men and I have no idea what I should think You "should" think whatever it is that strikes you as right to think. Nothing wrong with reminding the men around you that the person they're objectifying is a whole person who probably deserves better than being boiled down to solely their physical appearance, if that's what you're thinking, even if it's not the more stereotypical case of a man objectifying a woman.
|
|
4,156 posts
|
Post by kathryn on Sept 16, 2016 11:43:00 GMT
I'd object, and strongly, if the comments regarding the actor/actress were nasty or unpleasant. I think it's a nod to the quality of this open forum that I can openly admire the voice/face/arse of an actor without feeling I'm going to get battered by the pc brigade. If I said (and rightly) that Adam Linstead had gorgeous hair, who would complain? If I said (and rightly) that Darius Campbell was handsome who does it hurt? Beautifully put, londonmzfitz. I know on here I sometimes praise the physical appearance of a lady on stage, and mallardo and I have some running jokes about it all - but I'd hope it was always taken for what it is. Genuine compliment intended to make someone feel good about themselves, make their day that bit better. That is something the PC brigade seem to want to wipe out, and I really don't understand it at all. Yes, there's a VAST difference between "that's a nice skirt" and "nice skirt, what's it covering, love?" and PC has been excellent at eliminating the latter... ... but surely the simple "that's a nice skirt" needs to be re-claimed now, as we do on here, if only because a world without polite admiration would be a dull one indeed. There is a distinct difference between admiration and objectification. Nothing wrong at all with admiration! Objectification is a different kettle of fish entirely. MrsLovett, you have as much right to object to men objectifying men as women do to being objectified - it's your culture you want to improve. It's harder for straight women to complain about the things gay men say and do among themselves because we'd be accused of imposing our heteronormative views on a different culture. As much as phrases like 'PC Brigade' and 'Social Justice Warrior' get my back up (the latter provoking a knee-jerk reaction that the person is probably an idiot) I do agree that we seem to have moved to a place of counter-productive hypersensitivity about who gets to say what.
|
|
20 posts
|
Post by will on Sept 16, 2016 12:06:41 GMT
Hey all, While you guys were arguing I worked out the {Spoiler}{Spoiler - click to view} opening guitar riff which they play at the start of "There Will Be Sun" It's in B Minor and is at 70bpm. imgur.com/a/2bLDfThank you!
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 16, 2016 12:16:06 GMT
Hey all, While you guys were arguing I worked out the {Spoiler}{Spoiler - click to view} opening guitar riff which they play at the start of "There Will Be Sun" It's in B Minor and is at 70bpm. imgur.com/a/2bLDfThank you! Oh will, I knew you were sent to us for a reason! Thank you! (It's felt like Groundhog Day in here...)
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 16, 2016 12:21:57 GMT
No one was arguing. Jesus
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 16, 2016 12:23:08 GMT
Thank you for the responses, kathryn and baemax! That helps give me an insight into what others might be seeing in it that I'm not!
On objectification... I've read a few news articles recently based in part or entirely on the whole Aidan Turner/Poldark thing, some of which have raised the fact that male eating/exercise disorders are on the rise and linking this with the propensity for muscular male actors. I don't see that this increasing focus on male 'beauty' is going to stop anytime soon, so it will be interesting to see how that develops - eg will the scientists point to the same triggers for male as for female disorders of that type? (Though clearly, I would rather nobody had to suffer, whatever gender they identify with!)
I would never, ever compliment a stranger of the opposite sex, no matter how good I thought they looked in an outfit, because I'd find it really creepy if someone said it to me. (A colleague/friend is different, obviously.) In terms of saying someone I've seen on stage is hunky...? I don't have a huge problem with it, in fact I'm sure I've said it a hundred times over the years, but it's in the clear knowledge that I don't expect said person to strip off, I probably wouldn't fancy them in real life, I'm not being entirely serious, and I wouldn't dream of addressing it to said person's face!! ;-)
|
|
4,156 posts
|
Post by kathryn on Sept 16, 2016 13:30:20 GMT
No worries, Jean, sometimes you just don't 'get' what other people do from a show. It took me years before I 'got' Rent - I'd heard Seasons of Love sung at any number of events and seen the film version, and still didn't understand what the fuss was about. It took seeing Adam Pascal sing One Song Glory at a Teenage Cancer Trust concert for it to click for me.
I do think that we're a little harsh on new musicals, expecting the music to stick with us after a single listen, when we're also trying to follow all the details of story, staging and performance. Even with catchy verse-chorus-verse-chorus pop music it usually takes a few hearing for a song to really lodge itself in your memory - which is why radio stations have playlists that determine how often a song is played - and musical theatre songs usually have to do a more complicated job than that.
There's a reason why a lot of successful musicals started life as concept albums, or, these days, are strung together from pre-existing music.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 16, 2016 13:45:17 GMT
Hey all, While you guys were arguing I worked out the {Spoiler}{Spoiler - click to view} opening guitar riff which they play at the start of "There Will Be Sun" It's in B Minor and is at 70bpm. imgur.com/a/2bLDfThank you! {Spoiler - click to view} It's a pretty awesome rift. I tried to work it out as well on the piano, but this sounds more accurate, so nice one Will!
While some musical purists may argue that it doesn't open with a traditional overture, I think it is brilliant with the TV opening with the "Birdman" like drum beat, then the rift with the little van moving forwards in the dry ice. I just hope they don't put an awful overture in like they did with Matilda in NY!
|
|
20 posts
|
Post by will on Sept 16, 2016 13:55:04 GMT
{Spoiler - click to view}It's a pretty awesome rift. I tried to work it out as well on the piano, but this sounds more accurate, so nice one Will!
While some musical purists may argue that it doesn't open with a traditional overture, I think it is brilliant with the TV opening with the "Birdman" like drum beat, then the rift with the little van moving forwards in the dry ice. I just hope they don't put an awful overture in like they did with Matilda in NY! Thanks James! If you (or anyone else on this forum, for that matter) ever need a bit of a music worked out, I am more than happy to give it a go! Just message me! {Spoiler - click to view}I think the rift is fantastic which is why I had to get it down on paper! The van is just awesome. Such a small thing but is a really cool touch, especially if you are sitting in the stalls near the front and you see it come close to the edge. Also the drum throughout the "There Will Be Sun" song is just gorgeous. I'm currently in the process of working out the lyrics to: {Spoiler - click to view}There Will Be Sun and Small Town So please message me if you can help with them! Thank you!
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 16, 2016 16:28:40 GMT
Just a quick thought to add onto the objectification discussion. Is it actually objectification in this thread of Andy Karl when in the same breath people are also discussing his acting skills and performance? Surely objectification is seeing a person as nothing more than a sexual object to be looked at. None of us know Andy Karl personally so it's not like we can talk about what a great person he is but I guess I don't really see the issue in saying 'Andy Karl gives a great performance and is very attractive to look at' especially when being attractive is pretty necessary in order for his character to make sense. Likewise, if I see a film being discussed and someone has talked about the performance of an actress and THEN said how attractive she may be, I don't have an issue. It's when men just have nothing else to say about an actress/her character other than how much they want to have sex with her that it becomes icky and gross, especially as you often see them discuss all the merits of a male actor's performance and then just a tack on the end about the attractiveness of his female co-star.
|
|
1,325 posts
|
Post by londonmzfitz on Sept 16, 2016 16:37:16 GMT
Ah, badges badges. Also took advantage of the late evening discounted tickets, bought F28 for £30. I love this show! Got to listen to the lyrics and it's smart and funny. Yes some changes, the signposts on the revolve, which fell over a lot when I saw it two weeks ago appear to have been replaced by cast waving them behind Andy Karl. Did he wear a fur coat and drawers last time? Oh my ... The bench seats for Phil in the diner are replaced by bar stools. There's a bit of country style music to clap along to at curtain call that wasn't there previously. I loved it, and I may sneak in another last minute visit. Lots of chatter about how fun it was. And yes I stood at the end, it's all I could do to stop myself leaping onstage and snogging Andy Karl. Thanks so much to the poster who gave the heads up about the late discounts for that evening, I'm very grateful. My Convent school upbringing leads me to confess it's all my fault.
|
|
155 posts
|
Post by synchrony on Sept 16, 2016 16:58:42 GMT
IF ANYONE WOULD LIKE A TICKET TO TONIGHTS SHOW PLEASE PM ME.
Awful awful traffic means that I've missed the train. Next train is cancelled so I can't make the show :-(
Would feel better if the tickets isn't wasted.
Cost is £21, stalls seat.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 16, 2016 18:25:48 GMT
Wow excellent comments/discussion between the last time I stuck my head in here! I think the point about most of the praise for Andy Karl's appearence on here are followed by 'But boy can he sing/act/isn't he talented' shows the distinction between objectification. Likewise, I (and many others) have affectionatly commented on Julian Ovenden's er anatomy thanks to a certain play, but also I'm sure most of us are quick to add 'bloody good actor/singer though isn't he?' Likewise Mallardo and TheatreMonkey's long running joke about certain female performers. Anyway this is well covered more eloquantly by others, but was a very valid point to bring up. On the 'real life' examples, with the tenuous link that the story starts outside a theatre...I was waiting for a friend outside Billy Elliot having just got off a bus at Victoria, and a young man stopped and said 'Hello' to me, he then said 'I just wanted to say you look really pretty' (or words to that effect) I said 'Thank you' he said 'You're welcome, have a good day' and walked on. At no point there was no sense of ulterior motive, he simply paid me a compliment and walked on. That versus a man shouting 'Nice legs love' from a passing car, is the difference in day to day life I think... Anyway, back to the Groundhog... Excellent sleuthing those behind the spoiler tags
|
|
20 posts
|
Post by will on Sept 16, 2016 18:31:49 GMT
Excellent sleuthing those behind the spoiler tags If this means me, thank you!
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 16, 2016 18:34:31 GMT
Excellent sleuthing those behind the spoiler tags If this means me, thank you! Yes indeed it does enjoying your work!
|
|
1,325 posts
|
Post by londonmzfitz on Sept 16, 2016 18:59:02 GMT
I hesitate to add -many (many, many) years ago as I got off the bus to go to my office a young guy (same age as me -as I say, many many years ago) ran up after me, touched my shoulder and said "I just had to tell you, you've got a lovely bum". And ran away after the bus. I stood open mouthed, scarlet faced. But I remember it years and years (and years and years) later. Appalling really to think now, but for a bird with low self esteem (Catholic upbringing, remember) it was a memorable moment.
A man came up to my ex Ma in law in a pub some years ago and told her she looked lovely. And went back to talk to his mates. She smiled all night. Last week I told a young woman at a bus stop I loved her skirt (no, honestly, I did)!. Cath Kidson London scenes on a skirt.
|
|
4,810 posts
|
Post by Mark on Sept 16, 2016 22:03:06 GMT
Was expecting this to be good, but WOW it was so much better than I ever thought it could be. My only regret is not booking for it twice!
Hope it has a successful Broadway run and makes it to the West End for a run some day.
|
|