396 posts
|
Post by djp on Mar 1, 2016 0:10:59 GMT
The vocals were okay, but Maybe is a terrible song. It goes nowhere. If it had an ending ,and the dilemna was resolvable, the story wouldn't end as it does.
|
|
23 posts
|
Post by crunchemhall on Mar 2, 2016 12:54:45 GMT
More highlights from Saturday. Chris Peluso is fantastic.
|
|
2,151 posts
|
Post by richey on Mar 3, 2016 11:30:34 GMT
More highlights from Saturday. Chris Peluso is fantastic. I got goosebumps listening to that again. Chris sounded amazing on Saturday night. Unfortunately that was the one and only time I got to see him (saw Alistair twice)
|
|
716 posts
|
Post by theatre-turtle on Mar 4, 2016 21:45:46 GMT
Does anyone have and predictions or hopes for the feature film?
I had some ideas...
~ Cast an unknown for Kim as was the case when Lea and Eva were discovered. Preferably Vietnamese too...
~ cut the 'Maybe' section as it's not the strongest song and it doesn't advance the plot
~ use the live vocals technique of Les Miserables film to create a more theatrical feel
|
|
|
Post by d'James on Mar 4, 2016 21:48:41 GMT
Only cast people on merit, not their star value.
|
|
716 posts
|
Post by theatre-turtle on Mar 4, 2016 23:17:36 GMT
Only cast people on merit, not their star value. Russell Crowe to play the Engineer please
|
|
6,337 posts
|
Post by Jon on Mar 4, 2016 23:54:32 GMT
I think the live singing should only be used in certain scenes like Why God Why and Last Night of the World with prerecorded vocals for the rest.
I wouldn't be surprised if The Engineer, Chris, John and Ellen end up being names with Kim being the only unknown.
|
|
573 posts
|
Post by Dave25 on Mar 5, 2016 1:08:25 GMT
Does anyone have and predictions or hopes for the feature film? I had some ideas... ~ Cast an unknown for Kim as was the case when Lea and Eva were discovered. Preferably Vietnamese too... ~ cut the 'Maybe' section as it's not the strongest song and it doesn't advance the plot ~ use the live vocals technique of Les Miserables film to create a more theatrical feel NO LIVE VOCALS!!!! The Les Mis film is too literal. This material is per definition not literal. The Les Mis film is basically a theatre performance on a pavement in 1 take shots. Film should be much more than that. Use all the possibilities cinematography has to offer. Elaborate editing, fantastic cinematography, bigger than life fantasy sets. Using the songs in different ways, sometimes as a voiceover, sometimes as a soundtrack and sometimes mouthed by the character. A triumph of the fantasy. In "last night of the world" I want to see what is going on in their minds. A big romantic bamboo bed with a mosquito net, a fan, a muggy atmosphere, fantastic camera work and editing. Not because it was probably like that in real life (it was probably a dark empty room with only a mattress on the floor), but this is their thoughts being portrayed. Not literal. In "Thuy's death" after she shot him, I want to see a huge big black space with a choir of soldiers with ghost faces singing " this is he hour". This is the end of the world in Kim's mind. Not because it was probably like that in real life, but filming the scene in 1 take in an alley between a clothes line and a trash can (Les Mis way, too literal) is not going to work. With pre-recorded tracks a certain magic surreal reality is created that feels better/bigger than life. Then I can focus on the whole scene as a result instead of seeing an actor struggling with the notes. That is the magic I feel this film needs. I think the role of Kim is very difficult to cast, and that the role is like a diamond. It takes years to polish and sharpen it to make it perfect. I would like to see Tanya in the film. She is a wonderful actress. I love the song "Maybe" and think it could work very well in the film version, maybe the second verse as a kind of voice-over when we see the first meeting of Ellen and Chris in better times. Imagine what they could do with the Nightmare scene and Dreamland (Movie in my mind) when pre-recorded and wonderfully edited.
|
|
|
Post by SamB (was badoerfan) on Mar 5, 2016 21:02:43 GMT
I've always thought that the problem with Ellen's character is that we've barely seen her at all before the second half, and aren't given any reason to care about her relationship with Chris.
In the movie, one assumes they'd write one new song, to be eligible for Oscars etc, as they did with Les Miserables. I'd vote for a duet between Chris and Ellen, perhaps to be put in around I Still Believe, or even before Bui Doi.
|
|
57 posts
|
Post by Pennywise57 on Mar 6, 2016 2:22:16 GMT
I was there for both shows last Saturday. What an incredible day that was!! I'd not seen the show since early April last year before cast change and had forgotten quite what a powerful effecting show it is. I knew it was going to be a special day when I was sitting waiting for the matinee to start, and the cast can be heard back stage doing a huddle cheer. This then prompted what sounded like the entire audience to respond with a very loud roar! The whole atmosphere for both shows was electric. It was great seeing the new cast and some people I'd not seen before. First the matinee. Christian Rey Marbella was on as The Engineer and after initially being quite disappointed that Jon Jon wasn't on, I ended up really enjoying his performance. I much preferred his Engineer to his Thuy who I'd seen him play on my last vist to the show and didn't rate him then much at all. Natalie Chua was on as Ellen. I thought She was great and made Ellen much more likeable then Tamsin Carroll did. it was also really interesting having an Asian woman play Ellen as well as I feel it really added another interesting dynamic to Kim and Chris's relationship. I really liked Marsha Songcome as Gigi. Her voice wasn't quite as good as Rachelle Ann Go's but that's an impossibly high bar to try and reach. It was still very powerful though. Her Acting was great as well. It was great seeing Hugh Maynard as John as I'd not seen him both my previous 2 times I'd seen the show. I thought he was great, his "Bui Doi" was excellent. I really liked Sangwoong Jo as Thuy. His diction wasn't the best. It tickled me a bit when he sort of pronounced "he" as "she", but I feel he more then made up for it with his singing and acting. Chris Peluso as Chris was very good. His voice was great! I think I prefer Alistair Brammer in terms of acting choices though. Chris Peluso just didn't seem to get as emotionally involved in the character as Alistair Brammer did. Maybe though, this in truer to what a real Vietnam war veteran would act like, finding it hard to show they're true feelings. I finally got to see Tanya Manalang as Kim and she was amazing!!! what an Incredible little (literally, she's tiny) actress she is. She played Kim with so much vulnerability that you can't help but shed a tear or two (or several into a very well used tissue). I was particularly impressed with her acting in This Is The Hour {Spoiler - click to view}after Kim shot Thuy. It was just so intense. She was visibly shaking with Tears streaming down her face. You just felt so concerned for her. I also really liked her voice. Yes it isn't quite as powerful as Eva's but there isn't much in it if I'm honest. I was also really nice to hear certain phrases of songs sung as they were originally written (e.g. Paper dragons in the sky). Although that's not to say I don't like the way Eva sing's those bits as I do, it's just nice to hear them as they were originally written. To contradict what I just said though She did a nice little riff at the end if I'd Give My Life For You which I liked, so who knows, I guess I'm just easily pleased. Overall I loved Tanya and wish I'd seen her a few more times in the role. On to the evening Performance. I really didn't think the atmosphere for the matinee could be topped, just equalled but boy how wrong I was. The audience was amazing, with cheers for the end of each song getting louder and longer as the show went on. The roar at the end of "Bui Doi" was insane!! Everyone who performed at the matinee equalled if not bettered they're performance in the evening show. It was incredible to watch! Siobhan Dillon was excellent as Ellen. Her Maybe was flawless! Eva was just as great if not better than the last two times I saw her. Her voice was so strong at this performance. She has some belt doesn't she?! You could tell she put her all into ever song. It was really Interesting compering Tanya and Eva's acting choices as they both play the role quite differently. I really liked how they both acted the role, but for me Tanya wins on the acting side of things, with Eva not quite having the same acting ability that Tanya has. Not to Say Eva's Acting was bad, just different from Tanya's and I preferred Tanya's. Eva's acting was still really good though. Saying that though Eva done have a stronger voice than Tanya if only by a little bit, so I would say she wins on the vocal front (just). I've been trying to pick a favourite ever since seeing them both last Saturday, and I really can't. There both equally amazing in different ways!! Jon Jon was Incredible again, giving a Master Class performance, and given he'd been too ill to do the matinee. I don't think it showed one bit just incredible!! And if all that wasn't enough having Cameron Mackintosh, Alain Boublil and Claude-Michel Schönberg come out at the end and do speeches was fantastic! Just being in the presence of those three great men was amazing!! And the 25th anniversary gala in cinemas in the Autumn WOOOOO!!!!!! The day was rounded off nicely with a visit to the stage which was insane as I expected, with over half the length of the street full of people. I luckily managed to get to the front so got the talk to the cast and thank them when they came out which was a really nice way to end the night. It was an amazing atmosphere at stage door as well. Before any of the actors came out quite a few cast members started randomly poking they're heads out the various small windows above stage door. This would then be followed by a huge cheer from the street below. This went on for a good 10-15 minutes. The funniest case of this happening was when Hugh Maynard poked his head out one of them and said. "Do you guys want to meet my dance partner?" to which we all replied "yes". He then pops his head back in and a second later Cameron Mackintosh's pops his head out and says "Hiiii" - hilarious! Overall it was an Incredible day and probably the greatest theatre experience I've had so far and one that will live with me for a very long time!!! I'm really going to miss Saigon (sorry couldn't resist). Why god why (I'm on a roll) did it have to leave the west end this soon. 2017 can't come soon enough I will be seeing this show a lot when it tours. If we're lucky maybe we can have Tanya as lead on tour since Eva's off to Broadway, or is that Just wishful thinking? Anyway I better stop typing because this has taken far too long to write and I should go to bed. zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
|
|
2,151 posts
|
Post by richey on Mar 11, 2016 7:15:32 GMT
Tweet from Baz this morning that Danny Boyle is in talks to direct the film
|
|
1,878 posts
|
Post by distantcousin on Mar 11, 2016 11:31:24 GMT
I hear that too but I thought the staging was one of the big highlights of the show and the entire Kim nightmare sequence is one of the most memorable theatre moments I've ever seen. Does anyone who saw the original know how the two versions compare? It was more spectacular in the first version, the fence was just huge. Indeed it was, and the whole raked stage just took it to another level too
|
|
573 posts
|
Post by Dave25 on Mar 11, 2016 17:02:35 GMT
Tweet from Baz this morning that Danny Boyle is in talks to direct the film This is really interesting and exciting. I love his work. It has this very filmic and cinematographic look (better than life look, editing, camera movements and shots and colors) that could work perfectly for this film. I really hope they continue in this "non literal way" with this material. He definitely understands the filmmaking part. I just hope he understands the musical material too. That he understands the non-literal benefits of this material on film. And that he understands it is important to pre-record the songs as a filmic voiceover, as a non-literal triumph of the fantasy. Actors are perfectly capable of matching the acting with the song. Also editing takes it to the next level. It should be as non-live as possible. And most importantly, that he understands that separating acting from singing, what Hugh Jackman does (speaking 4 words and vibrate for 10 seconds on the last word) makes it unnatural. Instead you should combine it. Use people who can sing the whole sentence and act through the notes. Sing "Now come on ladies, settle down" and act it instead of speaking "now come on ladies, settle" and then sing the word "dooooooooooooown".
|
|
57 posts
|
Post by mrcurry on Mar 11, 2016 18:31:07 GMT
We do not understand what you mean by 'non-literal'? It could be shot in the Philippines, which means every extra could be a great singer.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 11, 2016 19:21:56 GMT
In "Thuy's death" after she shot him, I want to see a huge big black space with a choir of soldiers with ghost faces singing " this is he hour". This is the end of the world in Kim's mind. Not because it was probably like that in real life, but filming the scene in 1 take in an alley between a clothes line and a trash can (Les Mis way, too literal) is not going to work.
What yoh describe sounds very theatrical so I'm not really getting your point. Certainly more theatrical than the les mis movie
Miss Saigon needs some grit and realism to to help get past the over the topness of it all. Hopefully they will cut back a bit on the sung through stuff too and add some spoken lines
It will be tough to cast as only chris is a character that has potential to be played by a Hollywood name. If he isn't deemed too old jake Gylenhaal would be great, or maybe chris pine or zac efron (he can act when in a decent role...see The Paperboy)
|
|
573 posts
|
Post by Dave25 on Mar 11, 2016 19:53:51 GMT
I think the Les Mis film is too literal because it is basically a 1 take theatre performance on a pavement with people singing in eachothers face. Film needs much more than that, elaborate cinematography and editing.
The big mistake they made is that "toning it down" would be the solution. The truth is, it makes it weird and funny. Like I said, Hugh Jackman spoke 4 words and then vibrated for 10 seconds on 1 word. He completely disconnected the acting from the singing.
Especially with music and sung material, it is all about thoughts being sung, a triumph of the fantasy. "Last night of the world" filmed in an empty dark concrete room in a 1 take shot live singing in eachothers face for 4 minutes is not going to work. It needs over the top fantasy and very extensive cinematography. We want to see what is going on in their minds. Singing is per definition not realistic so you need to go all the way or not sing at all. "raw and real" lies in other things with this material.
Edit: About the casting, I think Chris needs to be a very strong natural singer, maybe Aaron Tveit or Jeremy Jordan. I think the only roles that can go to a celebrity name are Ellen or John. Maybe Lady Gaga as Ellen.
|
|
57 posts
|
Post by mrcurry on Mar 11, 2016 19:59:36 GMT
Miss Saigon needs some grit and realism to to help get past the over the topness of it all. Hopefully they will cut back a bit on the sung through stuff too and add some spoken lines No, absolutely not (sorry). Surely, musicals are meant to be 'over the top'. And why on earth does it need spoken lines ? It manages fine without them. The song `The Movie in my Mind` is meant to be about her dream, not a horror movie or nightmare. There is enough of that later on. It could be shot in the Philippines (for the cast) and Vietnam (Vietnam has the most amazing scenery).
|
|
573 posts
|
Post by Dave25 on Mar 11, 2016 20:07:18 GMT
Exactly, absolutely not. I HATE the constant switching between the acting and singing in the les Mis film. Sometimes even multiple times in 1 sentence. 1 word spoken and the next word vibrating.
Movie in my mind could be a wonderful scene, with a turning camera, a tear coming out of her eye when the refrain starts, zooming in on it, edited scenes of a perfect life of Gigi living in the USA, baking an apple pie, having a picknick with her family, when we hear the song as a perfect voice over, until her part ends and we see the horrible reality of her being in the nightclub again. Just some thoughts.
The music can be used in many different ways, we don't always have to see the person mouthing to the sung thoughts. We can see anything with the right cinematography.
|
|
57 posts
|
Post by Pennywise57 on Mar 12, 2016 13:21:40 GMT
Unrelated to the movie but I've just found this and think it's one of the most bizarre, yet somehow brilliant takes on the song I've heard. It really shouldn't work, but It does!!
|
|
|
Post by danb on Mar 12, 2016 13:29:17 GMT
Unrelated to the movie but I've just found this and think it's one of the most bizarre, yet somehow brilliant takes on the song I've heard. It really shouldn't work, but It does!! This is genius isn't it. Half of me wishes that Tim was born in another era so that his brilliance would be appreciated and the other half of me wants everyone else to catch up and appreciate the quality of both his vocals and his writing. I hope his Don weeks in 'Kinky Boots' remind the powers that be of his potential (especially when it comes to casting 'School of Rock'.).
|
|
57 posts
|
Post by Pennywise57 on Mar 12, 2016 15:52:51 GMT
Unrelated to the movie but I've just found this and think it's one of the most bizarre, yet somehow brilliant takes on the song I've heard. It really shouldn't work, but It does!! This is genius isn't it. Half of me wishes that Tim was born in another era so that his brilliance would be appreciated and the other half of me wants everyone else to catch up and appreciate the quality of both his vocals and his writing. I hope his Don weeks in 'Kinky Boots' remind the powers that be of his potential (especially when it comes to casting 'School of Rock'.). You're so right. He'd be perfect for School of Rock!!
|
|
573 posts
|
Post by Dave25 on Mar 17, 2016 12:16:55 GMT
Any casting ideas for the film version? Here are some people I think could be suitable (trying to find people who are actually good singers AND actors and the unavoidable mandatory "names", although I think quality should win from names anytime, but I understand that will never happen, so I included names too).
Engineer - Jon Jon Briones/ BD Wong
Kim - Tanya Manalang, she is a truly outstanding actress.
Chris - Aaron Tveit/Jeremy Jordan
Ellen - Amy Adams would be perfect for the role, type and acting wise/Another interesting choice could be Lady Gaga. She has a better singing voice for the material and she could make of Ellen an interesting counterpart in the love triangle.
John - No idea. This is a role that could go to a name. For example a great singing black popstar. Any names?
Thuy - No idea
Gigi - Nicole Scherzinger/Rachelle Ann Go
|
|
|
Post by tf on Mar 27, 2016 7:47:30 GMT
It was indeed filmed. Alistair and Rachelle Ann were brought back. I'm a little late to this party. In this March 20 report, Rachelle talked a bit about going back to film Miss Saigon for a DVD release. She is quoted, “The week before I flew back to Manila (the last week of January), we shot Miss Saigon for DVD and cinema release. So I was Gigi during the day, then Fantine at night!”
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 27, 2016 9:04:41 GMT
Any casting ideas for the film version? Here are some people I think could be suitable (trying to find people who are actually good singers AND actors and the unavoidable mandatory "names", although I think quality should win from names anytime, but I understand that will never happen, so I included names too). Engineer - Jon Jon Briones/ BD Wong Kim - Tanya Manalang, she is a truly outstanding actress. Chris - Aaron Tveit/Jeremy Jordan Ellen - Amy Adams would be perfect for the role, type and acting wise/Another interesting choice could be Lady Gaga. She has a better singing voice for the material and she could make of Ellen an interesting counterpart in the love triangle. John - No idea. This is a role that could go to a name. For example a great singing black popstar. Any names? Thuy - No idea Gigi - Nicole Scherzinger/Rachelle Ann Go There is no way they won't get some big names for this, the revival underperformed so there is no way they will risk a movie without a-list names. Which is even more difficult considering there arnt really any vietnamese/Asian hollywood names While both possibly too old now jake Gylenhaal or justin timberlake would be good for chris. Zac efron in the right role is a good actor (see the paperboy) and it could be a good challenge for him. John and ellen would probably be names. The Engineer could be a potential oscar worthy role but I can't think of a name that would be suited Definitely not aaron twait who has no screen presence based on grease and les mis.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 27, 2016 9:45:07 GMT
Ken Jeong would be a great choice for The Engineer.
|
|
573 posts
|
Post by Dave25 on Mar 28, 2016 12:18:39 GMT
Just some ideas:
Tanya Manalang (Kim)
B.D Wong (Engineer):
Nicole Scherzinger (Gigi):
Lady Gaga (Ellen):
Jeremy Jordan (Chris):
Are there any great black young (pop) singers and actors for John?
|
|
4,159 posts
|
Post by HereForTheatre on Mar 28, 2016 12:26:11 GMT
You don't need a star for every character. It will get by on just a few. Probably Chris, John and Ellen.
Jeremy Jordan would be brilliant as Chris but maybe they would want to go for a bigger name.
|
|
3,057 posts
|
Post by ali973 on Mar 28, 2016 13:56:03 GMT
I like the idea of Nicole as Gigi. I think Lady Gaga is a bit too edgy for Ellen, who is plain cookie cutter as they come. I would rather "save" Gaga for a Broadway revival of Funny Girl
|
|
716 posts
|
Post by theatre-turtle on Mar 28, 2016 13:59:20 GMT
Taylor swift for Ellen?
|
|
573 posts
|
Post by Dave25 on Mar 28, 2016 22:16:12 GMT
Jeremy Jordan would be brilliant as Chris but maybe they would want to go for a bigger name. I think it kind of benefits the story if Chris and Kim are a bit more "unknown" but very talented singers and actors.
|
|