4,039 posts
|
Post by kathryn on Dec 13, 2017 16:15:34 GMT
With mixed reviews the only way to find out how you'll feel about it is to see it yourself.
You may agree with the people who loved it - especially if you go in with lowered expectations. Plus, it is still in previews, so they may be trying different stuff out.
|
|
|
Post by QueerTheatre on Dec 13, 2017 16:29:31 GMT
I saw this on Monday & needed a few days to get my thoughts together. It's a noble failure with lots of nice things going for it (mostly Audrey Brisson's Jiminy) and a sensationally attractive chorus twink - but as a whole thing it just doesn't work. The concept of Pinocchio as the only human and everyone else as puppets sounds nice and clever - but in reality it just doesn't work & so is dropped halfway through. If it wasn't using the Disney songs i think we'd all be being even harsher - the nostalgia they invoke along with a few cute magic tricks are the only thing that kept this from being a total write off.
|
|
1,431 posts
|
Post by showtoones on Dec 13, 2017 16:47:45 GMT
I happened to love this show...clever, creative and wonderful performances. The storytelling is a bit on the nose and some of the backstory with the Fox doesn't work, but no one ever promised Disney here - it is a Tiffany/NT production. OIs it dark, yes - but i was crying toward the end.
Do we think it will get a transfer?
|
|
990 posts
|
Post by nash16 on Dec 13, 2017 18:21:21 GMT
I happened to love this show...clever, creative and wonderful performances. The storytelling is a bit on the nose and some of the backstory with the Fox doesn't work, but no one ever promised Disney here - it is a Tiffany/NT production. OIs it dark, yes - but i was crying toward the end. Do we think it will get a transfer? Definitely no transfer for this. It's got to survive it's reviews as well... Press Night tonight.
|
|
|
Post by crabtree on Dec 13, 2017 18:55:17 GMT
Do we think everyone has been jumping on the bandwagon with puppets, after war Horse, and they certainly have, but perhaps there's not always the understand of what a puppet is, or perhaps we are getting puppet fatigue. They sometimes seem a lay answer to many staging problems, but every so often they work brilliantly. Some of this team were involved with the gloriously reinvented Little Shop of Horrors at the royal Exchange, with a radically different Audrey II.
|
|
367 posts
|
Post by Ade on Dec 13, 2017 19:09:34 GMT
I’m very surprised by the negativity too. It’s very inconsistent and doesn’t know what it is, but it still flew by and does have some poignant moments that make the trip worthwhile. In regards the music, I actually think that a large part of it is that people are going in expecting a full musical and it’s very clearly not that. They may have set the scene better had they not bothered with the Disney music and just done original music to fit the tone (instead the music is a bit wedged in).
The stage does look bare but then I think that’s a combination of Crowley (he often seems to put a lot of effort into one or two scenes and leave the rest simpler) and Tiffany’s usual style not quite working on the expanse that is the Lyttelton stage (I feel like the staging would have felt a little less cold if they’d narrowed the proscenium a touch).
If I was to score it myself it would get a 3 stars, and I’ve definitely seen far more uneven productions get 3 stars from critics and comparative praise on here.
|
|
587 posts
|
Post by Polly1 on Dec 14, 2017 10:33:16 GMT
Nothing at all from press night yet? Seems very odd.
|
|
1,210 posts
|
Post by musicalmarge on Dec 14, 2017 11:38:46 GMT
I happened to love this show...clever, creative and wonderful performances. The storytelling is a bit on the nose and some of the backstory with the Fox doesn't work, but no one ever promised Disney here - it is a Tiffany/NT production. OIs it dark, yes - but i was crying toward the end. Do we think it will get a transfer? Definitely no transfer for this. It's got to survive it's reviews as well... Press Night tonight. The show isn’t transferring. My mole inside the NT said the internal response to the show is not good. They basically admit the show doesn’t go anywhere, no big numbers, doesn’t know if it’s a play or a musical, the creatives have issues with the book and direction and hasn’t been the creative success they wanted it to be. Such a shame. Still, I look forward to seeing it in January, and hope they continue to work on it.
|
|
|
Post by Honoured Guest on Dec 14, 2017 11:52:23 GMT
The show isn’t transferring. My mole inside the NT said the internal response to the show is not good. They basically admit the show doesn’t go anywhere, no big numbers, doesn’t know if it’s a play or a musical, the creatives have issues with the book and direction and hasn’t been the creative success they wanted it to be. This reads exactly like the press reviews of Les Miserables at the Barbican!
|
|
4,596 posts
Member is Online
|
Post by Someone in a tree on Dec 14, 2017 12:16:31 GMT
I really hope further work is carried out because I really enjoyed it and I believe it could be great - no word of a lie!
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 14, 2017 12:20:00 GMT
Its one of those shows where I can see why some don't liek it. If the reviews are bad, I won't be mad about it too much even though I enjoyed the show. Its not like Big Fish where I was genuinely pissed off how that show was reviewed. It didn't deserve that, that is a beautiful show.* *can you tell I'm still bitter.
|
|
1,465 posts
|
Post by foxa on Dec 14, 2017 12:45:58 GMT
|
|
|
Post by SamB (was badoerfan) on Dec 14, 2017 12:59:53 GMT
I really enjoyed it too, and I really liked the large puppets. In particular, I loved the Gepetto puppet, I thought it was really expressive, and really suited its voice and the way it moved. Perhaps with the large puppets it helps being far away? I was near the back of the circle, so I wouldn't have been able to see actors' expressions anyway, so for me it really worked with the puppets.
The show itself is good, but flawed. As someone said above, it could do with ten minutes of dialogue being trimmed in each half, and at least one more proper song near the beginning.
The only scene I really didn't like was the Pleasure Island sequence. I found it overlong and offputting, but then it's like that in the film too - the whole concept of that is really flawed. No sympathetic characters,it's VERY obvious to the audience what is happening ("lol they can't read"), and I could particularly have done without the whole Wee Jimmy Krankie routine we got from the main child character too.
Other than that, for all I was restless at times, I have to admit the ending really got me - and that's when I realised I was engaged and invested. So it definitely did something right.
|
|
369 posts
|
Post by MrBunbury on Dec 14, 2017 13:00:20 GMT
|
|
990 posts
|
Post by nash16 on Dec 14, 2017 13:10:43 GMT
Nothing at all from press night yet? Seems very odd. They've been embargoed so as not to impact on the corporate night tonight.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 14, 2017 13:12:38 GMT
|
|
885 posts
|
Post by lonlad on Dec 14, 2017 13:35:29 GMT
Saw it last night - very poor indeed. The few songs that are there get reprised endlessly and the second act grinds to a dead halt during the nasty and interminable Pleasure Island sequence. The book is underwritten and often doesn't make sense, and Tiffany's normally unerring eye for stagecraft seems pedestrian and lazy. Other than that, I loved it LOL! Some stood at the end as is de rigueur but there were a lot of grumpy, dismayed faces near me as we made our way up the aisles.
|
|
2,706 posts
|
Post by Cardinal Pirelli on Dec 14, 2017 13:44:45 GMT
Pulled it now, must have missed the embargo (although you can still see it via the cached page on Google).
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 14, 2017 13:54:28 GMT
Please m’m How many stars was it they give
|
|
1,465 posts
|
Post by foxa on Dec 14, 2017 13:56:30 GMT
Four stars.
Loved the puppetry.
Said his 12 year old grandson enjoyed it.
|
|
|
Post by Honoured Guest on Dec 14, 2017 14:03:56 GMT
Said his 12 year old grandson enjoyed it. Probably great-grandson, if it was Michael Billington. Or great-great-grandson.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 14, 2017 15:30:27 GMT
Four stars. Loved the puppetry. Said his 12 year old grandson enjoyed it. Thanks
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 14, 2017 15:30:50 GMT
Said his 12 year old grandson enjoyed it. Probably great-grandson, if it was Michael Billington. Or great-great-grandson. Too funny I wonder who will take over from him
|
|
969 posts
Member is Online
|
Post by alicechallice on Dec 14, 2017 15:41:10 GMT
You, hopefully.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 14, 2017 19:31:05 GMT
Went to the platform tonight which was interesting but I think the press night is tonight as it was busy and Tiffany mentioned it. Maybe something got lost in translation when the NT were changing it.
|
|
990 posts
|
Post by nash16 on Dec 14, 2017 19:54:10 GMT
Went to the platform tonight which was interesting but I think the press night is tonight as it was busy and Tiffany mentioned it. Maybe something got lost in translation when the NT were changing it. Last night was Press Night. Tonight is their Gala/Sponsors night. Reviews embargoed until after this night so as not to upset the funding peeps in case negative.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 15, 2017 0:27:51 GMT
No wonder they wanted the reviews embargoed Nothing but 3 stars other than Billington And criticism across the board Of the confused nature of this show And comments on the sloppy staging The NT really is the sh*ts of late Isn’t it I have always despised John Tiffany’s direction Done on a crappy budget But pretending it’s lavish using a bit of lighting And gauze on wires Just like Harry Potter Hardly the Chanel Haute Couture show For me he embodies everything tacky and awful and pretentious about the theatre After this cack up let’s see how quickly Disney make this mistake again One can only wonder what magic their own theatrical arm would have done with this show My sister who often comes to the theatre Passed comment How all NT shows are average and cheap looking What has happened there?
|
|
990 posts
|
Post by nash16 on Dec 15, 2017 3:20:38 GMT
3* is what it deserves. None of the mainstream papers have gone above this, beyond Billington as Parsely points out, but his review is more a summing up of events, rather than actual an actual critique. The West End Whingers review is brilliant: westendwhingers.wordpress.com/2017/12/14/review-pinocchio-national-theatre/But the review for Exeunt Magazine nails it in it's first two paragraphs. The show forgot its audience: "I’m sitting in the stalls at the Lyttleton, flanked by two kids. I know the girl to my left: this is Qeiva. She’s ten years old and one of my favourite people to take to the theatre. She’s smart and sparky and utterly unafraid to say what she thinks. By the end of this dark and overly complicated take on Pinocchio – part pantomime, part sh*t scary fable, part nightmarish puppet show and part schmaltzy musical – Qeiva is plaiting my hair and sketching in my notepad. I’m fairly tempted to join her, despite all the imagination and thought that has so obviously been poured into this show (perhaps a little much too thought, a little too many flourishes and not enough plain fun). Meanwhile, there’s the girl on my right. I don’t know this girl but she seems thrilled to be at the theatre. Some of the signs are good: she wriggles to the front of her seat and bounces about with excitement. She gets particularly animated when Pinocchio dances about with the other kids on stage – even if some of the children are wearing grey masks; drinking alcohol and puffing away on pipes; transforming into donkeys (the story just gets weirder and weirder). The girl to my right clearly wants to enjoy the vaudeville performance from the marionettes at Strombolio’s circus, but it feels a bit like a horror movie mixed with a kid’s birthday party (the marionettes look like murderous clowns) and it’s all a little confusing. There are moments that are genuinely frightening; I watch this girl hide beneath her mum’s arms, properly scared and increasingly alienated. And then there are great stretches of this show during which this girl visibly droops and slides down her seat, lost and painfully bored."
|
|
1,431 posts
|
Post by showtoones on Dec 15, 2017 5:32:42 GMT
Variety and The Hollywood Reporter are both raves.
Overall it did well...most of the reviews are mixed
|
|
990 posts
|
Post by nash16 on Dec 15, 2017 7:52:03 GMT
Variety and The Hollywood Reporter are both raves. Overall it did well...most of the reviews are mixed Really? This from Variety: "How ironic that “Pinocchio” should be a bit lifeless. With Disney handing over the keys to a cherished classic for the first time, “Harry Potter and the Cursed Child” director John Tiffany has served up an eye-popping production that is as stiff as a board. For all its staggering stagecraft, this “Pinocchio” is, for the moment, missing real soul." Can you link to the one you read?
|
|