2,452 posts
|
Post by theatremadness on Apr 15, 2017 16:14:10 GMT
This 'musical list' seems to have started doing the rounds on my facebook, so thought I'd bring it over here for some bank holiday theatre fun (and no doubt some heated discussions along the way)!
It's all been musicals that I've seen so far, but if you'd rather do a 'play' list, go ahead!
Here's mine:
Musical I love: The Drowsy Chaperone
Musical I think is underrated: Lend Me A Tenor
Musical I cherish: Les Misérables
Musical I think is overrated: Rent
Musical I hate: The Sound of Music
Musical I sob through: Parade
Musical that keeps me laughing: The Producers
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Something Rotten!
Musical with songs I skip: The Scarlet Pimpernel
Guilty pleasure musical: Legally Blonde
Game changer musical: Hamilton
Musical I'm most excited to see: Hamilton
Now you!
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 15, 2017 16:20:52 GMT
Oooo god!
Musical I love: In the Heights
Musical I think is underrated: Shrek
Musical I cherish: Wicked
Musical I think is overrated: The Lion King
Musical I hate: Stephen Ward
Musical I sob through: Rent
Musical that keeps me laughing: Legally Blonde
Musical I could listen to on repeat: The Bodyguard
Musical with songs I skip: The Phantom of The Opera
Guilty pleasure musical: Kinky Boots
Game changer musical: Hamilton
Musical I'm most excited to see: The Color Purple
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 15, 2017 16:28:20 GMT
Musical I love: Groundhog Day
Musical I think is underrated: The Threepenny Opera
Musical I cherish: Sweeney Todd
Musical I think is overrated: The Lion King
Musical I hate: Oklahoma! (bearing in mind it was an amdram from when I was 10 - but still had no desire to see or listen to it since)
Musical I sob through: Blood Brothers (I never cry, but I was so close here)
Musical that keeps me laughing: Avenue Q
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Michael Ball and Imelda Staunton in Sweeney Todd (generally, but at the moment School of Rock)
Musical with songs I skip: The Phantom of the Opera
Guilty pleasure musical: Shrek
Game changer musical: Matilda (wanted to chose something other than Hamilton)
Musical I'm most excited to see: Young Frankenstein (pretty much waited 10 years for this! - plus I know Hamilton will be virtually impossible)
|
|
4,029 posts
|
Post by Dawnstar on Apr 15, 2017 16:52:44 GMT
Musical I love: Top Hat
Musical I think is underrated: Several of Howard Goodall's
Musical I cherish: Zorro
Musical I think is overrated: currently on here 42nd Street
Musical I hate: Sweeney Todd
Musical I sob through: The SOund of Music
Musical that keeps me laughing: every Showstopper one I've seen (is this cheating?)
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Chess
Musical with songs I skip: all of them, I can't think if a single musical where I love every song equally
Guilty pleasure musical: Mamma Mia & Legally Blonde
Game changer musical: Show Boat (well, it was back in the 1920s)
Musical I'm most excited to see: I guess Half A Sixpence is currently top of my Need To See list
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 15, 2017 17:14:43 GMT
Musical I love: Hamilton
Musical I think is underrated: Pal Joey
Musical I cherish: Next to Normal
Musical I think is overrated: Dear Evan Hansen
Musical I hate: Big Fish
Musical I sob through: Next to Normal
Musical that keeps me laughing: The Book of Mormon
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Hamilton
Musical with songs I skip: Carousel
Guilty pleasure musical: If/Then
Game changer musical: Rent
Musical I'm most excited to see: Natasha, Pierre & the Great Comet of 1812
|
|
68 posts
|
Post by BGLowe on Apr 15, 2017 17:22:22 GMT
Musical I love: Carousel
Musical I think is underrated: Love Never Dies
Musical I cherish: Show Boat
Musical I think is overrated: The Lion King
Musical I hate: Stephen Ward
Musical I sob through: Les Miserables
Musical that keeps me laughing: Avenue Q
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Rent
Musical with songs I skip: Kinky Boots
Guilty pleasure musical: The Wedding Singer
Game changer musical: Jesus Christ Superstar
Musical I'm most excited to see: Hamilton
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 15, 2017 19:48:50 GMT
Musical I love: Dreamgirls
Musical I think is underrated: The Girls
Musical I cherish: Miss Saigon
Musical I think is overrated: Jersey Boys
Musical I hate: Once
Musical I sob through: Les Miserables
Musical that keeps me laughing: The Book of Mormon
Musical I could listen to on repeat: The Color Purple
Musical with songs I skip: Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Guilty pleasure musical: Viva Forever!
Game changer musical: Here Lies Love
Musical I'm most excited to see: Hamilton
|
|
5,840 posts
Member is Online
|
Post by oxfordsimon on Apr 15, 2017 20:14:26 GMT
Musical I love: Candide - it is far from perfect and has never found a finished form, but it is just wonderful
Musical I think is underrated: Our House - the best of the jukebox genre by a long way. Martin Guerre (original, unrevised version only) would be a close second.
Musical I cherish: Brigadoon - I have never seen it live but the score is simply wonderful
Musical I think is overrated: The Lion King. I think it is a great spectacle but the score just doesn't cut it for me
Musical I hate: The Sound of Music - it is a potentially interesting story ruined by schmaltz
Musical I sob through: Merrily We Roll Along gets me every time. And I always sob at the end of Blood Brothers.
Musical that keeps me laughing: Forbidden Broadway - pretty much every version has comic gems
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Many - but I like change!
Musical with songs I skip: There are duds in most scores.
Guilty pleasure musical: La Cage aux Folles - not really that guilty!
Game changer musical: Show Boat or West Side Story - each changed MT for future generations
Musical I'm most excited to see: Something really fresh and new - but there is nothing on the list at the moment.
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 15, 2017 20:45:01 GMT
I've tried to pick a different show for each category, but I could put multiple answers for many of them!
Musical I love: 42nd Street
Musical I think is underrated: The Color Purple
Musical I cherish: Once
Musical I think is overrated: The Lion King
Musical I hate: Sweeney Todd
Musical I sob through: Miss Saigon
Musical that keeps me laughing: Wicked
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Les Miserables
Musical with songs I skip: Phantom of the Opera
Guilty pleasure musical: We Will Rock You
Game changer musical: Rent
Musical I'm most excited to see: I hate to jump on the bandwagon but in this case I have to - Hamilton
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 15, 2017 21:19:41 GMT
Musical I love: Gypsy
Musical I think is underrated: (title of show)
Musical I cherish: Sweeney Todd
Musical I think is overrated: Hamilton- I'm sorry and I know it's good but I feel like everyone is jumping on the Hamilton bandwagon
Musical I hate: more dislike but blood brothers
Musical I sob through:Sunday in the park with George
Musical that keeps me laughing: The Producers
Musical I could listen to on repeat: at the moment a chorus line and falsettos
Musical with songs I skip: Ragtime
Guilty pleasure musical: 25th annual Putnam county spelling bee
Game changer musical: Fiddler on the roof
Musical I'm most excited to see: Follies and newly announced fun home
|
|
1,046 posts
|
Post by jgblunners on Apr 15, 2017 21:33:56 GMT
Some of these choices were really tough, but here's my list!
Musical I love: Wicked
Musical I think is underrated: Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (the West End version)
Musical I cherish: The Phantom of the Opera (I cherish the memory of performing in a University Production, rather than a memory of actually seeing the show)
Musical I think is overrated: The Lion King (film is great, but the stage version really disappointed me)
Musical I hate: I don't think I've ever actually hated a musical, but the show I've enjoyed the least has been wonder.land (the one by Damon Albarn)
Musical I sob through: bare: A Pop Opera (nb NOT bare: the musical)
Musical that keeps me laughing: The Book of Mormon
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Sunset Boulevard (ALW's most luscious score in my opinion)
Musical with songs I skip: Heathers
Guilty pleasure musical: Joseph and the Amazing Technicolour Dreamcoat
Game changer musical: 42nd Street (maybe not a game changer in the historical sense, but it certainly is for me as the first time I had seen such a spectacle on stage)
Musical I'm most excited to see: Follies
|
|
171 posts
|
Post by musicalfloozie on Apr 15, 2017 21:37:27 GMT
Musical I love: Les Miserable
Musical I think is underrated: Wonderful Town
Musical I cherish: Miss Saigon/Titanic
Musical I think is overrated: West Side Story
Musical I hate: Cats!!!!!
Musical I sob through: Miss Saigon
Musical that keeps me laughing: The Book of Mormon
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Jesus christ superstar
Musical with songs I skip: Wicked!
Guilty pleasure musical: Something Rotten
Game changer musical: Hamilton
Musical I'm most excited to see: Wizard of Oz
|
|
4,804 posts
Member is Online
|
Post by Mark on Apr 15, 2017 23:04:58 GMT
Musical I love: The Drowsy Chaperone (come on Southwark, please!!)
Musical I think is underrated: The Drowsy Chaperone
Musical I cherish: The Bridges of Madison County
Musical I think is overrated: The Lion King
Musical I hate: The Lion King
Musical I sob through: Blood Brothers
Musical that keeps me laughing: Something Rotten!
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Legally Blonde
Musical with songs I skip: Love Never Dies
Guilty pleasure musical: Bend it Like Beckham
Game changer musical: Rent
Musical I'm most excited to see: Come From Away
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 15, 2017 23:36:39 GMT
Musical I love: Sunday In The Park With George
Musical I think is underrated: Baby
Musical I cherish: Once
Musical I think is overrated: Hello Dolly
Musical I hate: Grease
Musical I sob through: Passion
Musical that keeps me laughing: On the Twentieth Century
Musical I could listen to on repeat: She Loves Me
Musical with songs I skip: Working
Guilty pleasure musical: Legally Blonde
Game changer musical: Cabaret
Musical I'm most excited to see: Hamilton
If I did this tomorrow it would most likely be different.....
|
|
|
|
Post by d'James on Apr 15, 2017 23:53:57 GMT
Musical I love: Starlight Express
Musical I think is underrated: Saucy Jack and the Space Vixens
Musical I cherish: Sister Act
Musical I think is overrated: Hairspray
Musical I hate: Ghost
Musical I sob through: Blood Brothers
Musical that keeps me laughing: Forbidden Broadway (sorry, easy choice)
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Any of the ones in the positive categories above.
Musical with songs I skip: I skip songs from most musicals. If I've bought the soundtrack, it's a good sign though.
Guilty pleasure musical: As long as it's legal, why should I feel guilty about it?!
Game changer musical: Tough one. Will have a think.
Musical I'm most excited to see: Maybe Hamilton but I'm really not that excited about it. Nothing else that is confirmed is getting me going though.
Special Mention: In The Heights - didn't fit into any of the categories above but it's very high on my list.
|
|
5,840 posts
Member is Online
|
Post by oxfordsimon on Apr 16, 2017 0:41:37 GMT
Now for the Play version
Play I love: Richard III - Shakespeare
Play I think is underrated: Murder in the Cathedral - Eliot
Play I cherish: The History Boys - Bennett
Play I think is overrated: I used to think this about anything by Pinter - but now having seen it done well, I have changed my mind completely! I think that Stoppard falls into this category - too clever for his own good.
Play I hate: Not the play itself - but the RSC/Wooster production of Troilus and Cressida has to be the worst piece of professional theatre I have ever seen. All the fault of the production - not Shakespeare
Play I sob through: The Laramie Project - Tectonic Theatre Project
Play that keeps me laughing: My Night with Reg - Elyot
Guilty pleasure Play: A good Ayckbourn - something like Season's Greetings
Game changer Play: Very difficult - but it could be between Nicholas Nickleby - Edgar (the epic scope of the adaptation) and Jerusalem - Butterworth (a modern play that captured the imagination)
Play I'm most excited to see: The Normal Heart - Kramer or The Lieutenant of Inishmore - McDonagh
Play I wish was kept away from the stage for the next 10 years: A Midsummer Night's Dream - Shakespeare
|
|
185 posts
|
Post by boybooshka on Apr 16, 2017 10:36:39 GMT
Musical I love: Company
Musical I think is underrated: Evil Dead The Musical
Musical I cherish: Billy Elliot
Musical I think is overrated: Evita
Musical I hate: Fame
Musical I sob through: The Color Purple
Musical that keeps me laughing: Avenue Q
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Parade & Spring Awakening
Musical with songs I skip: Hair
Guilty pleasure musical: Exposure The Musical
Game changer musical: A Chorus Line
Musical I'm most excited to see: Fun Home
|
|
1,102 posts
|
Post by zak97 on Apr 16, 2017 11:01:15 GMT
Musical I love: Top Hat
Musical I think is underrated: From Here to Eternity
Musical I cherish: Oliver
Musical I think is overrated: Matilda
Musical I hate: Kinky Boots
Musical I sob through: Funny Girl
Musical that keeps me laughing: The Girls
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Half a Sixpence
Musical with songs I skip: Les Miserables
Guilty pleasure musical: Grease
Game changer musical: Showboat
Musical I'm most excited to see: 42nd Street
|
|
43 posts
|
Post by sayers500 on Apr 16, 2017 11:48:12 GMT
Musical I love: Bend it Like Beckham
Musical I think is underrated: Anyone can Whistle
Musical I cherish: Sweeney Todd
Musical I think is overrated: Wicked
Musical I hate: Joseph and his Technicolor Dreamcoat
Musical I sob through: Billy Elliot
Musical that keeps me laughing: Something Rotten
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Ragtime
Musical with songs I skip: Hamilton
Guilty pleasure musical: Shrek
Game changer musical: Avenue Q
Musical I'm most excited to see: Caroline, Or Change
Play I love: Violence and Son- Gary Owen
Play I think is underrated:Evening at the Talkhouse- Wallace Shawn
Play I cherish: A View from the Bridge- Arthur Miller
Play I think is overrated: Hamlet- Shakespeare
Play I hate: Dinner with Saddam- Anthony Horowitz
Play I sob through: King Lear- Shakespeare
Play that keeps me laughing: Unreachable- Anthony Neilson
Guilty pleasure Play: The Beaux Stratagem- George Farquhar
Game changer Play: Blasted- Sarah Kane
Play I'm most excited to see: The Ferryman- Jez Butterworth
Play I wish was kept away from the stage for the next 10 years: Any plays by Tom Stoppard
|
|
19,787 posts
|
Post by BurlyBeaR on Apr 16, 2017 12:13:28 GMT
Musical I love: Sunset Boulevard
Musical I think is underrated: Dirty Rotten Scoundrels
Musical I cherish: Les Misérables
Musical I think is overrated: Book of Mormon
Musical I hate: Cats
Musical I sob through: Parade
Musical that keeps me laughing: Xanadu
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Phantom
Musical with songs I skip: Gypsy
Guilty pleasure musical: Xanadu
Game changer musical: Don't know.
Musical I'm most excited to see: Follies
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 16, 2017 13:23:30 GMT
And....plays
Play I love: The Winter’s Tale - Shakespeare
Play I think is underrated: Camino Real – Tennessee Williams
Play I cherish: Uncle Vanya - Chekhov
Play I think is overrated: A Doll’s House – Ibsen
Play I hate: Antony & Cleopatra - Shakespeare
Play I sob through: Our Town - Wilder
Play that keeps me laughing: The Country Wife - Wycherley
Guilty pleasure Play: Absent Friends - Ayckbourn
Game changer Play: 4:48 Psychosis - Kane
Play I'm most excited to see: Any new play at the Royal Court
If we were talking about productions, again that list would be different and include more devised or non text work.
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 16, 2017 13:34:24 GMT
I agree with 4.48 Psychosis. We did a production with that script for out A Level final piece. We did it in the round, dressed as monks. The audience sat on the floor and we had pornography projected on the ceiling, masturbation with a cross, mounting audience members and dropping our robes at the end and dancing around the outer of the audience naked whilst lighting candles around them. We got an A*
The great thing about that piece is you can do literslly anytjing with it, it is all based on interpretation of the words as there is no stage directions or right way to direct it!
|
|
5,061 posts
|
Post by Phantom of London on Apr 16, 2017 19:09:42 GMT
Musical I love: Billy Elliot
Musical I think is underrated: Parade/Bridges of Madison County/Aspects of Love
Musical I cherish: Hairspray/Les Miserables/My Fair Lady/Matilda
Musical I think is overrated: Wicked/Dear Evan Hansen/Charlie and the Chocolate Factory/Into The Woods
Musical I hate: Chicago/Motown/On Your Feet/An American in Paris
Musical I sob through: Next to Normal/Les Miserable/Carousel/Miss Saigon
Musical that keeps me laughing: The Book of Mormon
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Come From Away/Waitress
Musical with songs I skip: Never Ship Anything.
Guilty pleasure musical: Billy Elliot/Les Miserables
Game changer musical: Anything Goes/Rent/Oklahoma/Jesus Christ Superstar/Hair
Musical I'm most excited to see: Hamilton/Follies/Bring It On
|
|
1,933 posts
|
Post by LaLuPone on Apr 16, 2017 19:23:30 GMT
Musical I love: Dreamgirls
Musical I think is underrated: Into The Woods
Musical I cherish: Wicked
Musical I think is overrated: Mamma Mia
Musical I hate: The Lion King
Musical I sob through: Rent
Musical that keeps me laughing: Hairspray
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Wicked, Dreamgirls, Rent, Hairspray, Into The Woods, come on most really!
Musical with songs I skip: Miss Saigon, Evita
Guilty pleasure musical: Little Shop Of Horrors
Game changer musical: Rent
Musical I'm most excited to see: Miss Saigon on Broadway (mainly because I never saw that amazing cast in London)
|
|
2,702 posts
|
Post by viserys on Apr 16, 2017 19:41:04 GMT
Musical I love: Rent
Musical I think is underrated: Legally Blonde
Musical I cherish: Starlight Express
Musical I think is overrated: Wicked
Musical I hate: Miss Saigon
Musical I sob through: Blood Brothers
Musical that keeps me laughing: Book of Mormon
Musical I could listen to on repeat: Notre Dame de Paris
Musical with songs I skip: Dreamgirls
Guilty pleasure musical: Starlight Express
Game changer musical: Hamilton
Musical I'm most excited to see: Natasha, Josh Groban and the Comet
|
|
