|
|
Post by johnjohotspur on Oct 14, 2024 18:00:05 GMT
More style than substance in this underwhelming production. Not the first time I've seen the National throw all its considerable resources at a show but fail to get the basics right. David Oyelowo plays Coriolanus as a decent soldier who gets a bit peeved at being asked to play the politician. That's about it. There is little sign of Coriolanus' arrogance or contempt for the masses, and far too little vocal variety. Coupled with some pretty run-of-the-mill acting from some others, this leaves a hole where the tragedy should be. The key relationships with Aufidius and Volumnia are under-developed, leaving Menenius and the tribunes to dominate. Meanwhile we had a parade of what are fast becoming modern-dress-Shakespeare cliches - scenes played as press conferences, live video projections, yet another cuboid set, plus an annoying soundtrack that the poor performers had to fight against. The money wasted on these peripherals would have been better spent on more heavyweight actors (ideally better-known actors too - the auditorium was half-empty on Thursday night) and hiring some extras. You cannot expect five or six placard-waving actors to fill a space the size of the Olivier. |
|
|
|
Post by johnjohotspur on Oct 14, 2024 18:05:23 GMT
Saw this a few weeks back- it was enthralling, great cast, rapturous reception at the end. Certainly a “ heavy weight” performance from David Oyelowo - very impressive in a difficult part. remember him as Henry VI years ago - nice to see the wheel come full circle. Another one that seems to generate diversity of opinion - all good :-)
|
|
|
|
Post by orientfan on Oct 15, 2024 9:18:42 GMT
My benchmark is the Charles Dance/RSC production from 1989. On the night we were there, almost the entire Cabinet were in the front rows.
This is actually one of my favourite Shakespeare plays, and Oyelowo brings a lot to the second half of this production. But the set was probably the winner.
|
|
|
|
Post by Jan on Oct 16, 2024 6:36:48 GMT
Strangely I partly agree with almost all of the reviews of this, positive and negative, because it was very very uneven. For every very good scene there was one where a character was declaiming and the rest of the actors were just standing motionless in a semi-circle listening. Overall it was a bit plodding and one paced. I think the issue is that Lyndsey Turner is just a very inexperienced Shakespeare director - as far as I can see she's only directed one Shakespeare play before which was Hamlet as a star vehicle for Benedict Cumberbatch. Given that taking on this difficult play in this difficult theatre was ambitious. With the same cast I think their regular Shakespeare director Simon Godwin would have done better.
I liked David Oyelowo as Henry VI but I think this part was less suitable for him - he was a bit too naturalistic and not extreme enough and also didn't engage with the audience in any way at all - for example when I saw McKellen play the part in this theatre he left us in no doubt that his contempt for the common people extended to the entire audience. I though the best performance by far - very detailed - was Jordan Metcalfe as Junius Brutus.
3*
|
|
105 posts
|
Post by youngoffender on Oct 16, 2024 8:17:14 GMT
It's a shame to see this is now being papered. On the face of it this had all the makings of a National hit (Shakespeare, name lead, a good number of 4* reviews), but there's clearly some negative energy around this show that is making people stay away.
|
|
|
|
Post by Jan on Oct 16, 2024 11:39:51 GMT
It's a shame to see this is now being papered. On the face of it this had all the makings of a National hit (Shakespeare, name lead, a good number of 4* reviews), but there's clearly some negative energy around this show that is making people stay away. It’s never been a popular play and the only way it’s ever filled a large theatre is with a sensational leading actor and production (Alan Howard was a notable RSC one). Small-scale productions have done better. |
|
1,826 posts
|
Post by Dave B on Oct 23, 2024 12:52:08 GMT
Saw this last night, our usual front row seats so intensely close to the action.
Mainly fall in with the mixed reactions, it felt more style than substance. I like David Oyelowo a lot and thought he was really good at the almost petulance, his way or the highway and stubbornness. He carries the character of Coriolanus with an intensity, almost a burning sense of purpose and hard to take my eyes off him... but I did feel Coriolanus was a little one note, not much else to bring to the character. I've not seen it before so don't know if this was play or production. Unfortunately it meant that I didn't see much in the relationship with his mother that would be so key later on.
Peter Forbes' Menenius was excellent, really grounds the first half and then excels in the second act when begged to then beg Coriolanus himself. The rest of the cast were all good with many get a moment to shine and do really well which I liked
Set design is pretty excellent, really impressed by that and it combines with light and sound to be effective throughout. Excellent fight/action scenes too.
3 stars good. Quite happy with the value for money of my ticket.
|
|
