923 posts
|
Post by Snciole on Jul 2, 2019 21:10:30 GMT
I didn't understand the public debate suggestion at all. Sounded a bit macho and vaguely threatening to me tbh Exactly. His status means he will have the mental advantage and being a man gives him a physical advantage. He won't fight these women on the stage physically (imagine) but he certainly has more power than they do to get the right people on his side in. I respect his journey but this is a man who has gone out of his way to appear to more ethnic than he really is. I suspect he didn't want this African story told by a white woman and a mixed race woman despite it not being his story to tell either.
|
|
2,348 posts
|
Post by zahidf on Jul 2, 2019 21:12:35 GMT
The young Vic e.t.c aren't denying the underlying aspect of the original writers complaints though. They are just saying they changed it so much they don't deserve credit. The tone of the rebuttal is very legalistic and aggressive to. I don't think it's correct to say that the YV hasn't denied the complaints. The YV statement says "Whilst we appreciate that they were involved in exploring ideas for a project based on Idris’ original concept, the truth of the matter is that MIF and Green Door did not feel their proposed direction was artistically viable. It was decided by these producers that the show needed to go in a very different direction with a new writer attached, using Idris Elba’s original concept as the starting point." They then say that they reached out to the writers about the new direction, but this wasn't accepted. Whether this was done in a fair or legal manner or not may be open to debate, but so far as I can tell, we can't yet be sure which side is correct here. In any case, my feeling is that you're being slightly unfair in dismissing the rebuttal as 'legalistic and aggressive'. The Young Vic is a formal organisation, which means that their communication, even on ostensibly more informal tools like Twitter is different to two upcoming writers writing something for a website. Not least because any Tweets could presumably form part of legal discussions which may follow. A more friendly tone may be nicer, but if they truly are not at fault, then they may not want to make a statement that could later negatively affect them. Similarly, Kwame is writing from his position in the organisation, not simply as a member of the public. I mean, this is why in most of our jobs we might not be able to speak/email with clients/customers/whatever with the same freedom as you do while with your friends. Don't get me wrong, I accept that on the whole Twitter allows people with less power to make their grievances heard by the wider public as noted by crowblack . And I accept that it may be in this instance that the YV/Kwame are at fault. However, my point is simply that the stuff we pick up from these things (it's too cold, too legal, they should respond more quickly, etc.) isn't necessarily a reflection of the underlying ethical & legal issues at hand: The tone of a tweet has no real bearing on which side is right here. I guess that's the issue: how much was elba's vision and the writers? TBH, I'm sure it's happened loads before: the less starry writers get pushed out for the names. That seems to the most likely situation here! May be the case of course that everything was 100% above board but I feel the original, detailed statement is very convincing
|
|
2,348 posts
|
Post by zahidf on Jul 2, 2019 21:13:34 GMT
Sounded a bit macho and vaguely threatening to me tbh Exactly. His status means he will have the mental advantage and being a man gives him a physical advantage. He won't fight these women on the stage physically (imagine) but he certainly has more power than they do to get the right people on his side in. I respect his journey but this is a man who has gone out of his way to appear to more ethnic than he really is. I suspect he didn't want this African story told by a white woman and a mixed race woman despite it not being his story to tell either. I don't think race has anything to do with it. Don't really want to go down that road
|
|
2,962 posts
|
Post by crowblack on Jul 2, 2019 21:19:47 GMT
one voice leading to an outpouring of people speaking out. I really hope so - I've seen it happen in so many arts/media places, by people who you'd think would act more conscientiously.
|
|
923 posts
|
Post by Snciole on Jul 2, 2019 21:20:51 GMT
I think race is key to this. Key to the production (Toni wrote it from personal experience), key to story Idris and Green Door wanted to tell and yes KKA as one of the leading BME faces of a large theatre.
The expectations on him as a black man in theatre are far greater than on him as a Black AD. If he doesn't play the game or in this case plays the game badly and get a caught that will be far harder to come back from than if he was a white man. I find his response disappointing. He speaks non-specifically about his record with female creatives but I am sure he treats his equals well. His disrespect for these women is apparent; even down to the disregard of their work in his statement.
Will this be his downfall. Not directly but if it causes the floodgates to open then expect a resignation. This is terrible for the YV's image
|
|
18,813 posts
|
Post by BurlyBeaR on Jul 2, 2019 21:51:47 GMT
I don’t know if I’ve ever mentioned this but I actually wrote Hamilton a good five years before that Miranda bloke got his mitts on it.
Ok, it wasn’t a musical, it was all white casting and it was about Neil and Christine Hamilton’s struggle with the media.
BUT IM ENTITLED TO A 🤬 CREDIT
|
|
|
Post by partytentdown on Jul 2, 2019 21:55:37 GMT
I think race is key to this. Key to the production (Toni wrote it from personal experience), key to story Idris and Green Door wanted to tell and yes KKA as one of the leading BME faces of a large theatre. The expectations on him as a black man in theatre are far greater than on him as a Black AD. If he doesn't play the game or in this case plays the game badly and get a caught that will be far harder to come back from than if he was a white man. I find his response disappointing. He speaks non-specifically about his record with female creatives but I am sure he treats his equals well. His disrespect for these women is apparent; even down to the disregard of their work in his statement. Will this be his downfall. Not directly but if it causes the floodgates to open then expect a resignation. This is terrible for the YV's image The YV has come out of scandals unscathed before. It's not been that many years since there were threats of boycotts over staff treatment. People have short memories.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 2, 2019 22:00:40 GMT
I don’t know if I’ve ever mentioned this but I actually wrote Hamilton a good five years before that Miranda bloke got his mitts on it. Ok, it wasn’t a musical, it was all white casting and it was about Neil and Christine Hamilton’s struggle with the media. BUT IM ENTITLED TO A 🤬 CREDIT Posts like this are exactly why I stopped posting here, £100 this post gets deleted and the topic is locked! 🙄
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 2, 2019 22:03:42 GMT
I don’t know if I’ve ever mentioned this but I actually wrote Hamilton a good five years before that Miranda bloke got his mitts on it. Ok, it wasn’t a musical, it was all white casting and it was about Neil and Christine Hamilton’s struggle with the media. BUT IM ENTITLED TO A 🤬 CREDIT Posts like this are exactly why I stopped posting here, £100 this post gets deleted and the topic is locked! 🙄 Like clockwork, I’ve head a DM threatening to ban me, KKA is it you?
|
|
18,813 posts
|
Post by BurlyBeaR on Jul 2, 2019 22:05:58 GMT
Posts like this are exactly why I stopped posting here, £100 this post gets deleted and the topic is locked! 🙄 Like clockwork, I’ve head a DM threatening to ban me, KKA is it you? Err, no you haven’t had a pm from any of the admin team threatening to ban you, so that’s a lie I’m afraid.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 2, 2019 22:12:04 GMT
What I mean is that, most of us have very little concrete information to go on, and nothing that could be described as truly 'objective' at this stage. I think this is the massive problem with the social media age. It's all about short messages and immediate responses, which is not an environment that's conducive to understanding the actual situation. There's a pressure on everyone to pick a side and make a stand, and waiting so you can have an informed opinion isn't an option. 100% this.
|
|
18,813 posts
|
Post by BurlyBeaR on Jul 2, 2019 22:20:44 GMT
And the natural temptation is to support the ‘underdog’ isn’t it. And maybe they HAVE been screwed over, from the noises being made from people in the industry it seems entirely possible. But the only way to prove it is by going down the legal route which doesn’t seem to be an option for cost reasons. So it will come down to who you want to believe.
|
|
572 posts
|
Post by princeton on Jul 3, 2019 0:04:25 GMT
The only 'evidence' in the public domain are the various statements which have been issued today. These indicate that whilst there is clearly disagreement about the events which led to the original concept being jettisoned and replaced by the current incarnation - the only party which has involved been since the original commission to now is Green Door Films aka Idris Elba.
It would seem that the commission was between Tori, Sarah and Green Door Films, though it's unclear exactly what the terms of that commission were - and this may be key to the expectations that each of the parties had about any subsequent reworking of the project.
Somewhere along the line the Manchester International Festival joined Green Door (Idris Elba) as lead producer and together decided that the work was not progressing in the right direction and invited Kwame Kwei-Armah and the Young Vic to help develop the project and become a third lead producer - and presumably a new contract was drawn up. Here's where it gets a bit messy - and without seeing contracts difficult to know where responsibility lies - but lots of one-to-one conversations and three person meetings seemed to take place - but the planned creative get-together of all four leading players never took place. Then people said that they wouldn't meet with each other - and it's almost impossible from the evidence which is out there to actually work out who was the first one to say 'no I'm not meeting'. Then Tori and Sarah were removed from the project. And somewhere in the middle of all of this the MIF and the YV announced the project - billed as "Created by Idris Elba & Kwame Kwei-Armah" - with Idris describing Kwame in the MIF press release as "a writer with such tremendous vision"
So what we're left with is an unholy mess with lots of finger pointing, people who are understandably aggrieved, lawyers making money, a company of actors currently in Manchester fine-tuning a production and finding themselves in the eye of a storm, a leading London theatre looking rather less welcoming than it would like to be and social media going into meltdown - based on potentially unreliable narrators (on all sides).
As noted above this wouldn't be the first time creative teams have changed during the development process (for example, Disney sacked the director of Frozen after a series of workshops) and along the Cut in 2002 the Old Vic announced that Matthew Warchus would be taking over as Artistic Director in due course - only to find himself deleted from that part of the theatre's history when in 2003 Kevin Spacey was introduced in a blaze of fireworks as the new AD.
Of course that doesn't justify any wrongdoing that took place in this instance - I just don't think it's clear (or at least on the information which is out there) what exactly the wrongdoing is, who was responsible and where the buck stops. Is it breach of contract, is it poor communication, is it IPR theft, is it the patriarchy in full swing or is it a lack of human decency? And who made the ultimate call - Idris, John McGrath from MIF, Kwame - or everyone - or no-one and it's an inevitable part of a creative process?
I'm sure the story will continue to run and further details will be revealed. For now it's all rather unsavoury - and counter to the cozy picture theatre likes to paint of being a collaborative, friendly environment - which is clearly a dramatic construct in itself rather than reality - as this, and lots of other recent offstage happenings, seem to suggest.
|
|
|
Post by Seriously on Jul 3, 2019 0:11:58 GMT
Posts like this are exactly why I stopped posting here, £100 this post gets deleted and the topic is locked! 🙄 Like clockwork, I’ve head a DM threatening to ban me, KKA is it you? Do tell us more ldnexpat. Who threatened you?
|
|
5,278 posts
|
Post by mrbarnaby on Jul 3, 2019 1:25:44 GMT
If this isn’t resolved in the women’s favour, I will never return to the young vic whilst Kwame is in his position. It’s a disgrace.
|
|
1,427 posts
|
Post by showtoones on Jul 3, 2019 5:05:46 GMT
All the YV needs to do is pay Tori and Sarah for their work and give them an additional material by: credit.
It’s not difficult and everyone wins, but by doing so the YV in a sense admits wrongdoing which is probably not something they are prepared to do.
|
|
749 posts
|
Post by horton on Jul 3, 2019 6:10:19 GMT
I would be interested in comparing the 2 scripts / drafts to see exactly how different they are.
The Young Vic at present, has failed to offer a coherent and compelling version of the narrative; instead it's a legal defence of the right to behave in an ethically questionable way.
|
|
Xanderl
Member
Not always very high value in terms of ticket yield or donations
|
Post by Xanderl on Jul 3, 2019 6:11:14 GMT
Bridget Minamore, who did the above interview with Elba and Kwei-Armah, tweeted ... and then retweeted this ...
|
|
2,348 posts
|
Post by zahidf on Jul 3, 2019 6:25:36 GMT
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 3, 2019 6:42:21 GMT
The thing that gets me is that KKA had a huge amount of support at the start of his writing career to get it off the ground through the NT etc - you'd think he would want to pass that on to other emerging creatives.
I worked in a job a while ago in which I had very glancing experiences with him and he was one of the rare people who was friendly and nice to the lowly serfs so this is very depressing. And the responses from him and the YV are extremely ill-judged in tone.
|
|
|
Post by partytentdown on Jul 3, 2019 7:23:27 GMT
|
|
367 posts
|
Post by MrBunbury on Jul 3, 2019 8:45:30 GMT
The whole thing looks rather depressing and KKA and the YV (a theatre I really love) are really coming out badly. It would be fairly simple to compare the scripts between the old "Tree" and the new "Tree" since there have been workshops with the original work. I find Tori and Sarah' detailed report quite convincing, at least for the point that they should deserve credit. This situation has turned a bit sour my relationship with the Young Vic.
|
|
5,588 posts
|
Post by lynette on Jul 3, 2019 11:42:42 GMT
Judging by comments here and on twitter Kwame’s response hasn’t helped him much. Two points: 1. Even if a ‘project’ has been rewritten the original creators are credited in some way ( and in theatre of this kind surely would prob be involved along the line) 2. A public discussion would do what exactly? Sounds like the man wants a bloomin’ trial or something like the Tory leader so called debates. Ridiculous. Demeaning and who does he think he is? I’m thoroughly disgusted. Just seems brutal and a total carve up to me. Is this how it is done? Well, no more Young Vic for me.
|
|
|
Post by mrkringas on Jul 3, 2019 12:00:45 GMT
I have no idea what to think of this particular case.
But I do know that the Young Vic is consistently the flagship London theatre of its scale that is grounded in the London I live in.
It goes above and beyond with the local community and young people that other non profits in the area could learn from.
Thats not a space I plan on withdrawing support from anytime soon.
|
|
2,348 posts
|
Post by zahidf on Jul 3, 2019 12:29:45 GMT
I'll see how it develops before deciding. Also if any more stories like this start coming out...
|
|
|
Post by Fleance on Jul 3, 2019 12:45:14 GMT
I have no idea what to think of this particular case. But I do know that the Young Vic is consistently the flagship London theatre of its scale that is grounded in the London I live in. It goes above and beyond with the local community and young people that other non profits in the area could learn from. Thats not a space I plan on withdrawing support from anytime soon. The Suppliant Woman was a particularly good example of that. But of course, that was the previous administration. And it's still important, no matter what noble enterprises the new Young Vic leaders may be involved in, that they proceed with integrity,
|
|
4,594 posts
|
Post by Someone in a tree on Jul 3, 2019 14:20:18 GMT
I wonder how this going to pan out
Cancellation of show Court case Protests during the performances Resignation
?
|
|
1,846 posts
|
Post by NeilVHughes on Jul 3, 2019 14:40:58 GMT
The surprising intervention was the KKA twitter reply, assume it was cleared, usually the opening gambit is a legal précis as released by the Producers to take control of the narrative and stem the rumours and close down the story.
The likelihood is, Idris Elba will either, or be seen to engineer a resolution that pacifies all parties, otherwise the piece he was instrumental in getting off the ground and appears truly proud of will remain tarnished and is most probably why he has not publicly given his opinion so far.
Of the Production itself I am unsure what it exactly is, a play with songs, a musical or some kind of installation piece.
|
|
18,813 posts
|
Post by BurlyBeaR on Jul 3, 2019 15:13:32 GMT
It’s been getting quite a bit of adverting on tv in the northwest, not the general MIF advert but a separate ad for this this specific piece. It’s not enticed me to book.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 3, 2019 15:15:49 GMT
I wonder how this going to pan out Cancellation of show Court case Protests during the performances Resignation ? The show will go ahead. Court Case not likely as the girls said they couldn't afford to pursue legal action. Protests? Maybe a few silent protests in the form of boycotts. Resignation? Maybe if there's enough voices in force. Feel like this has the potential to fizzle away, like YV have seemingly already tried to make happen.
|
|